Following some feedback…
13 Aug
Hey there Wordsmith Laners,
When I started this blog in July 2009, I was pretty down in the dumps. At the time, I’d been suffering from situational depression for a few months, which made it hard to write (let alone do other things, like be my normal self). I had also been made redundant from a job that I did not actually like, which made things ten times worse. I was out of a job for five months or so, and in that time, all I wanted to do was WRITE.
My inspiration for this blog came from the fact that when I started out as a freelancer a few years before, there was not many places I could turn for some REAL advice on breaking into the industry, let alone as a freelancer. There were PLENTY of things I had to learn from my own, and I copped a lot of rejection in those early years, and made a lot of mistakes that I learnt from.
I figured that I didn’t want this difficulty to be the case for everyone who wanted to freelance in magazines or journalism. I wanted to help. I wanted to give them the content they weren’t really getting anywhere else, whilst sharing with them my own wordsmith journey. In all its mistakes, faults and glories. I remember excitedly telling a big time magazine writer about my idea, and she laughed and told me I better be charging for all that content I was giving away. But I never have, because it was never about that.
In the past two weeks, I have gotten some feedback about my blogging. Apparently I need to be more humble. I shouldn’t speak to you as though you are my students, and I shouldn’t be proud of my achievements or successes the way that I am. I should reply to all your comments. And beauty blog in a manner that doesn’t resemble advertising. I shouldn’t say that I am a good writer either.
So I am going to lay my cards on the table, once and for all. I am going to say what I am about, and what I think, and suss out whether or not I should keep blogging to begin with. It’s not that I want to silence the critics, because I believe in free speech and know that criticism is an essential part of the game. But I also know that keeping this blog up and running costs me time and money. Money because I fund things like domains and applications on wordpress (and occasionally prizes and the like), and money because I have lost a lot of time that I’d otherwise devote to freelance writing to blogging. That’s right, I blog more than I write these days, because my readership has grown and I thought I would devote more time to the demand, even at the risk of my bigger career. And you know what, it’s not just that.
Most writers don’t get to come home from their full-time jobs and drink a glass of wine on the couch at the end of the day, and I am one of them. I come home after working eight hours, have dinner and a shower, and try to blog or write until 11pm, which is when I go to sleep. My shoulders actually hunch over because I am always hunched over my laptop, and when I go to the osteopath to get treated for my back, I am always berated for spending too much time at my computer. What I am trying to say is that this blog doesn’t serve a lot for me. At the risk of sounding arrogant, I do this to help you guys out. Because I genuinely care about your career goals. This means that some of the time I could otherwise devote to my own writing career, which I make money off, is coming to this blog. And there’s no point in me running it if you are not enjoying it, or thinking that you don’t want to learn from my lessons. (And FYI, those bars you see for ONYA and Trespass are not for advertising, they’re my support for friends who have done really well to start and work on online mags that serve Gen Y.)
Anyway, another criticism is my lack of replies to your comments. But I just have to say, when I do get comments that require a response, I email that person directly. And I have developed some great relationships with some of you. In fact, one reader sent me an email two days ago, to thank me, because I put her in touch with one of my contacts for some casual temping work, and she now has a job at a women’s lifestyle magazine at ACP. Sometimes, people ask me questions (via the comments) that they might not want the answers to broadcast for other readers to see, which is why I like to keep things private.
I’m also sorry if my confidence has come across as arrogance. People who have read this blog since its establishment would know that I am a woman of many issues and insecurities where my writing is concerned. I have made a lot of mistakes, get a lot of rejection and work really hard for whatever successes I have earnt. Moreso, how could I possible motivate and encourage you if I was always negative? Why would you bother pursuing freelance journalism if all you heard was the bad bits? a big part of it self-esteem and self-motivation in the face of rejection, so when I say ‘I am a good writer’, it is me attempting to go on despite my setbacks. I think if I was arrogant I wouldn’t bother trying to help people out, I would want to hog all the advice to myself. Plus, I don’t mean to speak to you as students. That is SO UNINTENTIONAL. I teach sometimes too, so I am sorry if that comes across in my writing. I just consider so many of you my ‘baby wordsmiths’ and I want your success more than YOU KNOW. And lastly, I am not being a show-off when I say I have a lot to do. And immodest when I say I am exhausted. I really am exhausted. I work five days a week, do the usual housework, blog, try to write, stress about everyone else’s problems (that’s just me), plan my wedding, go to uni. I juggle. It’s part of the reality, it’s really not a lie.
And finally, I am sorry if my beauty posts sounds like advertisements. I get a lot of press releases and invitations to things, and a lot of opportunities to endorse many a product. About 20% of these make it to the blog. I make it my mission to write about things that I LOVE or things that I have tried. Yes, maybe I suck as a beauty writer, but it was never in my big plan. I started writing beauty because a lot of you asked about the industry and I couldn’t dish advice out on a subject I knew NOTHING about. So my beauty writing is a learning curve. And when I rave about a product in a story or open letter, it’s because I actually loved it. You can tell which products I like because they are always featured: Benefit, Trilogy, Planet Earth & Burt’s Bees (esp their cuticle cream and blemish stick). And Nivea body moisturisers, and the scent of anything by MOR (which I just recently discovered) float my boat too.
So that’s it. That’s me, stripped bare, cards on the table. The thing is, I am not invincible. I still have not developed my thick journalist skin. Things still hurt. Especially when they’re coming from people who don’t actually know me. I am a non-fiction features writer. I can’t write my intentions to make sure they’re not misread, and you can’t feel my emotions when I write. So what comes across as arrogance is just me encouraging myself in the face of discouragement.
So where do we go from here? I am thinking of eliminating my own personal writer’s journey from the blog; no more tales from my own experiences and no more lessons in skills textbook (especially when those lessons stem from my own). I honestly don’t want to sound like a sook, and I don’t want to be misinterpreted. You might be sick of me, or you might want to learn your own way. Either way, Wordsmith Lane can change enough to be a generic writer’s blog with writer’s interviews and writerly news. Up to you guys.
In the end, I can’t help thinking that this is still a personal blog. MY OWN. Which makes me entitled to my own thoughts and opinions. But at the same time, criticism gets me bad. Maybe I am still in the early stages of my career and very unequipped to deal with criticism (depsite what I think). I value your advice and your feedback. If you want change, I will do my best to accomodate.
A lot of stuff to think about and plenty to mull over this weekend. As for me, I’m over and out.














